Understanding the Difference Between Social Engineering vs. Cybercrime

Businesses today face a rapidly evolving threat landscape, particularly when it comes to cybercrime and financial fraud. One significant area of confusion for many organizations is the difference between cyber insurance and crime insurance, specifically in relation to social engineering attacks. We’ll aim to clarify these distinctions and highlight why understanding them is critical for comprehensive risk management.

What is Social Engineering?

Social engineering involves exploiting human psychology rather than technical vulnerabilities. Essentially, it's about tricking individuals into willingly providing sensitive information and credentials, or even transferring funds to fraudsters. Common examples include:

• Phishing Emails
  Fraudulent emails posing as legitimate entities (e.g., banks, executives) designed to deceive employees into revealing sensitive data or initiating unauthorized transactions.
• Business Email Compromise (BEC)
  Attackers impersonate senior executives or trusted vendors, manipulating employees into transferring company funds.
• Pretexting
  Scammers pretending to be IT support or other trusted sources to gain login credentials under false pretenses.
• Vishing (Voice Phishing)
  Scammers using phone calls to trick individuals into revealing sensitive information or confirming details for fraudulent transactions.

Unlike traditional cyberattacks, social engineering doesn't require breaking into networks—it's about deceiving people directly.

Differences Between Social Engineering and Cybercrime

While social engineering manipulates individuals, traditional cybercrimes exploit technical vulnerabilities:

• Ransomware: Malware encrypting company data and demanding a ransom.
• Data Breaches: Unauthorized access to steal sensitive data.
• Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS): Flooding networks to crash systems.
• Credential Stuffing: Automated scripts testing stolen login credentials across multiple accounts.

Social engineering and traditional cybercrime differ fundamentally: social engineering targets human trust, while other cybercrimes exploit technological weaknesses.

How Insurance Policies Cover The Risks of Social Engineering and Cybercrime

Insurance policies differentiate clearly between these two categories:

Cyber Liability Insurance

Cyber policies typically cover network breaches, data privacy issues, ransomware, system restoration, legal fees, and notification expenses. However, they often exclude social engineering losses unless specifically endorsed.

Crime Insurance

Crime insurance, particularly when enhanced with a social engineering endorsement, directly addresses financial fraud like fraudulent wire transfers and business email compromise. This type of policy usually provides broader and higher limits for social engineering losses compared to cyber insurance.

For example, if an employee mistakenly wires $250,000 due to a fraudulent email request, a standard cyber policy without specific endorsements may deny the claim. However, a properly endorsed crime policy can provide reimbursement, potentially up to full limits.

Why You Need Both Cyber Insurance and Crime Insurance

Businesses frequently assume their cyber insurance covers all types of cyber-related incidents, including social engineering. This assumption can lead to significant coverage gaps. To mitigate this risk, businesses should:

• Review existing policies carefully, focusing on endorsements and exclusions.
• Consider separate crime insurance policies with explicit social engineering fraud coverage.
• Understand policy limits—crime policies often allow higher limits for these types of financial losses.

Emerging Trends and Policy Evolution

Insurers continue refining policy language to address evolving threats, especially with the rise of sophisticated scams involving artificial intelligence and deepfake technologies. This evolution includes:

• Tighter definitions and narrower policy language regarding social engineering coverage.
• Higher deductibles or sublimits for social engineering-related claims on cyber policies.
• Increased premium costs when endorsing social engineering coverage on cyber policies.

Moreover, insurers are increasingly requiring enhanced security measures like multi-factor authentication (MFA) and advanced fraud detection systems as prerequisites for coverage.

Best Practices for Businesses

To effectively protect against financial and cyber risks:

• Maintain both comprehensive cyber and crime insurance policies.
• Regularly review policy wording, endorsements, and limits.
• Implement robust cybersecurity and anti-fraud training programs.
• Work closely with specialized insurance brokers who understand both the cyber and crime insurance landscapes.

Social engineering and cybercrime risks aren't going away; they're growing more sophisticated. Ensuring your business is adequately covered requires understanding these distinctions clearly and implementing policies that specifically address these evolving threats.

At Flow Specialty Insurance, we can assess policies and help agents find the cyber insurance coverage they need for their clients.

‍

FAQs

Do small businesses need cyber insurance?

Cyberattacks are rising. Over 60% of small and medium businesses have reported cyber incidents. And data breaches are expensive: The average cost of a data breach was $4.88 million in 2024.

What does cyber insurance cover?

Cyber insurance covers costs related to data breaches, ransomware, legal defense, regulatory fines, business interruption, and more.

What should a cyber insurance policy include?

At minimum, it should include data breach response, business interruption, ransomware extortion, regulatory compliance support, and social engineering fraud coverage.

How do businesses assess their cyber risk?

Through security audits, employee training evaluations, vendor risk assessments, and consulting specialized insurance brokers.

Does general liability insurance cover cyberattacks?

No. Cyber incidents require a separate, dedicated cyber liability policy.

What industries need cyber insurance the most?

Healthcare, finance, e-commerce, technology, and education are among the most targeted and regulated sectors.

‍